Anyone had any good success with plastic/rubberized cases

I got a silicon case off ebay that is really nice. Adds a little bulk but I think it would really protect it if dropped. It does attract lint a little and makes it hard to remove or put it in a pants pocket which is why I stopped using it. But for some folks it might work great.

How are those protectors? I always here they make it hard to see the screen outside and get bubbles underneath them. Do they mess with the touchscreen at all?

Yeah eddie they do work great. I had mine since day one as well and love it.

Yes the clamshell/ combo case is the best,  it's a belt clip and a case that also surrounds the phone this with a screen protector and skin will ensure the phone is protected.
 
Shell / Holster Combo this is the official name for it part #PART# VZW6200HOC for verizon

I got my Droid Incredible over the weekend (1 cent from Amazon Wireless btw) and I ordered the innocase II and the holster. It looks great, fits great and the holster seems quite solid.
I'm very pleased with the case holster combo. I found that on eBay for ten dollars less than from the manufacturer site and with free shipping. I like having the holster/belt clip separate from the case because sometimes the phone rides in the shirt pocket. The clip on the case swivels but remains in the location you select. I'm a police officer and I have destroyed phones on calls so I'm always on the lookout for a good case or holster. So far this one appears to fit the bill. I suppose a screen protector will follow next after I do a little more research.

Where are you people finding the innocase for the Droid Incredible? Are you on the same internet that I am?  I cant find them ANYWHERE!

I had a Seidio Innocase and holster for my HTC Kaiser (TytnII) and loved them. However what I hate about Seidio is that they are not up front about ETA of thier products, and leave you terminally waiting for their new products to be released.

I waited and waited and waited for the car dock/adapter for the Kaiser and it never was produced despite reassurances from Seidio reps in forums such as this that the product was "on its way, just be patient". So we never did get an integrated case/holster/clip/car solution that was promised when I purchased the case/holster combo. It was a major downer for me on the part of Seidio.

My advice is to buy whatever case/holster is available and NOT wait for Seidio to pull their heads out of thier asses. History shows it will be a looooooooong wait.

And just because a product is listed as "coming soon" on their website does not mean it ever will. The Kaiser was the number one most popular device for YEARS according to the PDA database http://pdadb.net/ and still they never produced the full kit compatible with their own case/holster.